Start on the back
Record the player or subject, card number, manufacturer, and any printed set or subset name. A year in the copyright line is a clue. Compare it with the release checklist, especially when a season spans two calendar years.
Match the exact issue
Search the manufacturer’s checklist by set and card number. Check the name, team, language, and design. Pay attention to inserts and subsets that carry a different numbering scheme.
Check for parallels and variations
Compare foil color, patterns, borders, image variations, and stamped numbering. Look for a factory-stamped number such as 23/99. That number describes a print run and is separate from the card number or a grading certificate serial.
Record what you can confirm
Take a clear photo of each side and write down the confirmed details. Keep uncertain information in your notes until a checklist or a matching example confirms it.