Grading standards

QuadFacet grades card condition on a 1–10 scale. The overall grade reflects centering, corners, edges, and surface on the card at the time of inspection.

The four facets

Check the original card design before interpreting what you see. For example, an asymmetric image can be part of the design, while a surface impression or peeling edge is a physical condition issue.

Centering
Compare opposite borders and the position of printed elements on each side. For borderless designs, use the intended layout and visible reference points.
Corners
Inspect every tip for rounding, exposed fibers, folds, or compression. A sharp-looking front corner can still show wear on the reverse.
Edges
Follow the full perimeter for whitening, chips, rough cuts, and separation between layers. Dark borders and foil finishes often make edge wear easier to see.
Surface
Examine both faces for scratches, dents, creases, stains, and print defects. A change in viewing angle can make a mark visible on glossy or reflective stock.
10Gem Mint
Exceptional overall condition with strong centering, sharp corners, clean edges, and a surface free of meaningful visible defects.
9.5Mint+
Condition between Mint (9) and Gem Mint (10).
9Mint
Very clean overall presentation with a minor imperfection, such as a small print mark, slight edge wear, or a modest centering shift.
8.5Near Mint–Mint+
Condition between Near Mint–Mint (8) and Mint (9).
8Near Mint–Mint
Strong eye appeal with light wear or a small visible flaw on one or more facets.
7.5Near Mint+
Condition between Near Mint (7) and Near Mint–Mint (8).
7Near Mint
Light corner or edge wear, a minor surface mark, or noticeable off-centering may be visible on close inspection.
6.5Excellent–Mint+
Condition between Excellent–Mint (6) and Near Mint (7).
6Excellent–Mint
Moderate wear in one area or lighter wear across several areas. Surface marks and uneven borders can be more apparent.
5.5Excellent+
Condition between Excellent (5) and Excellent–Mint (6).
5Excellent
Visible handling wear such as softened corners, edge chipping, or surface scratches. The design remains well defined.
4.5Very Good–Excellent+
Condition between Very Good–Excellent (4) and Excellent (5).
4Very Good–Excellent
Clear wear across several areas. A light crease, more pronounced edge wear, or surface discoloration may be present.
3.5Very Good+
Condition between Very Good (3) and Very Good–Excellent (4).
3Very Good
Pronounced corner and edge wear, creasing, or surface wear that is readily visible during ordinary viewing.
2.5Good+
Condition between Good (2) and Very Good (3).
2Good
Heavy handling wear or damage such as multiple creases, staining, or substantial edge and corner wear.
1.5Fair
Condition between Poor (1) and Good (2).
1Poor
Severe wear or damage. Tears, paper loss, deep creases, or heavy staining can substantially affect the card’s appearance.

What the grade tells you

Condition is one part of how collectors assess a card. The player, issue, scarcity, demand, and comparable sales all matter when deciding what a card is worth. Use the grade together with the card description and the photographs in its certificate.

Verify a certificate